Mon’Arc en Ciel Monaco

Born and raised in Monaco. Anais Berruti knew as a teenager she was gay. “I never had any problems with my family, friends, school, or workplace. I always accepted how I was and the most important thing for me was that my family accepted it. So, I have always been open about it. The fact that it was Monaco made no difference,” says Anais.

“But I know for my friends, who are Monegasque, it is more complicated because they feel that they are regarded negatively. I never had that feeling.”

Anais is one of four women who have co-founded Mon’Arc en Ciel, the country’s first LGBTQIA+ association. They will “defend and promote the individual and collective rights and freedoms of LGBT people in the Principality”, which is why they chose May 17 – International Day Against Homophobia, Transphobia and Biphobia – to launch their website.

Mon’Arc en Ciel was created last month by Anais and her wife Isabelle, and Laure Bernardi and her wife, Cynthia Salvanhac. The two couples each have a child less than a year old. As Anais explains, “We discovered as we were doing the paperwork to register our child at the crèche. On the one hand we are considered as a family in terms of our joint income, but on the other hand they say that my wife had no legal parental authority. I had to sign an authorisation for her to be able to pick up our child.”

Isabelle and Anais Berutti, Cynthia Salvanhac and Laure Bernardi at PrideMonaco 2024.

The 35-year-old describes how she was “shocked and upset” about having to sign an authorisation for her wife. “She was there with me and I felt bad. I know that it wasn’t the fault of the director who was just passing on the information from her superiors. Legally, she had to do it. So I signed the authorisation.”

Immediately after, Anais sent an email to the crèche management to explain what had happened but the result wasn’t what she had hoped. “They called me and apologised, and said they would take a look at our file and put me as a single mother. Which wasn’t the idea at all. I had hoped that things had progressed, but in fact I was considered as a single mother and my wife doesn’t figure on the crèche documents.”

Anais and Isabelle discovered their friends were encountering the same situation. “This is what made us react, to change this, for us and for our children. Our goal is to have our family situation recognised.”

The idea of creating an association had been in discussion before Anais was pregnant. We thought it would be important for the future. But it was this issue with the crèche that made us actually do something.”

It’s not only the inequality at the nursery that Anais and Isabelle are facing. “My wife and I are resident and we work in Monaco and covered by the CCSS [Monaco’s social security] who take into account both of our incomes as a single household. When I was pregnant, I made an appointment with the CCSS to see if my wife was entitled to parental leave, in the same way that fathers have paternal leave when a child is born. And she is not. So, again, on the one hand they take our incomes into account but on the other hand we don’t have all the entitlements of a family. Even with the CCSS, in some services we are considered as a couple, but in others I’m considered as a single mother. It’s absurd.”

Anais says she feels well looked after in Monaco and doesn’t “feel any discrimination or judgement” when social services say that their hands are tied by the government, by the law, and that they can’t do anything. According to ILGA’s Rainbow Map, Monaco is the least developed among Western European countries in terms of LGBTQ+ equality and out of 49 European and Central Asian countries, only five rank lower than the Principality – Belarus, Russia, Armenia, Turkey, and Azerbaijan. The country’s low placement on the LGBTQ+ ladder is not helped by its failure to recognize legally binding marriages from other countries, which impacts civil and economic rights of couples.

And although Monaco rebuts that its hands are tied as its Constitution establishes Catholicism as the state religion, Malta, whose population is 96% Catholic, is ranked number on the Rainbow Map for equal rights for same-sex couples.

“There are a lot of people who live and work in Monaco who are paranoid. They think there is a risk because they have a false image of Monaco. I do not agree that there is any risk. Monaco depends on a certain image for its economy but the people who live and work in Monaco are very welcoming and there is not the danger that people believe. But people are afraid that it might affect their job. I don’t know anyone who has been thrown out of Monaco for being gay.”

Anais says, “Monaco is small, people talk. I have never been uncomfortable saying that I’m in a couple with a woman. But we are young. We are not the same generation as older people who have maybe had different experiences.

“Some individuals feel there’s a risk of being regarded negatively, so they keep quiet. We understand, and that’s also why we created this association. To tell these people that, even if they don’t want to speak out, the association will do it for them.”

You can become a member of Mon’Arc en Ciel, donate time and skills to their association or support their cause. See their website for more. Contact: 07 80 98 00 03 or monarcenciel@monaco.mc.

Article first published on May 17, 2024. Photos: Good News Monaco.

Marina Ceyssac, High Commission for the Protection of Rights

Jean Charles Gardetto, Lawyer

Christine Pasquier-Ciulla, Lawyer and National Council

Béatrice Fresko-Rolfo, National Council and General Rapporteur on the rights of (LGBTI) people: Committee on Equality and Non-Discrimination, at the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE)

Gavin Sharpe

“I felt trapped in my corporate success,” says Gavin Sharpe. “However corporate life had seduced me, it controlled me rather than the other way around.”

His recruitment company, SSQ, was independently ranked by The Sunday Times as one of the best companies to work for and was placed as the most profitable in its sector. “I was losing my identity. Something was missing and that something was me,” he states.

Having grown up in a small village in Hertfordshire and studied in London, once Gavin sold his company he yearned for a different lifestyle and kinder climate. “My parents had lived in Monaco and it felt familiar. It was one of those defining moments and the start of an adventure that began some six years ago and which feels like it is just unfolding,” he describes about relocating to one of the safest countries in the world.

Gavin jumped off the corporate bus and into a career that “allowed me to be authentic and congruent. I had enjoyed my own therapy and developed a passion for the field of psychotherapy.”

As a counsellor, coach and therapist, he is now on his true life path. “The calling had always been there. When I was ready to listen, it spoke to me. I wish it was less of a cliché but it is true,” he admits.

Comparing the amount of time and money we spend on our physical wellbeing (yoga, Pilates, breathing, healthy eating) versus our mental wellbeing, Gavin observes, “I bet we are more comfortable telling the boss that we are leaving the office early for a Pilates class than for a therapy appointment. Men are certainly more likely to say they have a personal trainer to lose weight rather than a therapist to help with their erectile dysfunction!”

He believes the taboo arises from a lack of awareness and education about mental illness. “Sadly, some people do not seek out treatment due to the self-perceived stigma. Perhaps one good thing to emerge from the Covid pandemic is that there seems to be a willingness to talk about the cost on our mental health. Who knew that when you lock up humankind and hide the key, it impacts our emotional wellbeing?”

Gavin wants to make mental health more accessible and is excited by a new partnership with Rivera Radio. “Wellbeing Window” will be an hour on the first Wednesday of each month at 9 am CET addressing a topic on mental health and inviting listeners to write in with their questions.

“It was brave of Rob Harrison and Sarah Lycett to have me on the Full English Breakfast Show back in 2019. We broke new ground. I think there was a fear that people would be drowning in their cornflakes, and as a result, listeners would tune out. Instead, we found them tuning in. When I appeared last on New Year’s Eve, I ended up staying for longer than scheduled as the number of listeners writing in rocketed. Rob and Sarah have an amazing talent in being able to discuss deep and meaningful subjects that touch us all and seconds later they have us roaring with laughter over something meaningless and mundane.”

For Gavin, there is another dimension to wellbeing that has been forgotten. In his upcoming book on how we can follow our true life path rather than the one we find ourselves on, he has dedicated a chapter to Financial Wellbeing. “We all have money scripts, a set of beliefs or values about money. Do I deserve money? Is money good or bad? What does money represent to me?” he asks. “When a couple argues about money, it is never about the money per se. It is about what the money represents. I have studied financial disorders and run money intensives with individuals and couples to help them explore these deep-rooted issues.”

On Covid
Gavin’s appointment calendar was already pretty busy before a pandemic forced us to face unprecedented issues as couples. “You could have been the most solid couple in the world but if you are in lockdown in a small apartment with three children and home schooling, your relationship will likely have felt the strain. Couples who were struggling before the pandemic have unsurprisingly felt the cracks widen.”

He adds, “I think it is unhealthy for couples to be living and working together with this level of intensity. Relationships need to breathe and need spontaneity and creativity to fuel ongoing desire. The pandemic has the potential to kill desire – unless you are single in which case, you might not know what to do with your desire! There is usually hope for struggling couples. The key is to seek help before contempt sets in.”

For Gavin, the popular media is full of titillating stories informing us that the divorce rate will spiral while others indicate the opposite. “The truth is probably somewhere in between. What we do know from studies of past pandemics, such as SARS and Ebola, is that psychological reactions such as panic, depression, loneliness, anxiety, stress, grief, anxiety and PTSD are common. This obviously has entered into our relationships during the Covid pandemic.”

On Expats
A study released this year showed that US expats were two and a half times more likely to experience anxiety and depression than their US-based counterparts. “I am sure it is the same for expats based in Monaco and the South of France,” Gavin insists.

“Expats sometimes tell me they feel trapped and long for their roots. Many have moved around in childhood and coming to the Riviera is just one more notch in their portable bedpost. When we move around, we experience loss. We leave behind family, friendships, rituals and routines. I think the wellbeing litmus test for expats is the extent to which we allow ourselves to grieve those losses or do we just move on?”

For Gavin, expats can also suffer from “I should” syndrome. I should be happy. Look where I live. I have no right to be miserable. (He once replied, “If I was married to your husband, I’d be miserable, too.”) “The point is that we have to allow ourselves to experience our emotions wherever we live. Living by the sea is not a passport to happiness. We still have to work at it.”

In this part of the world, he sees men and women facing different challenges. “There is a power dynamic which troubles me. Many women move to join their breadwinner husbands. The men carry on largely as before while the women often find themselves dependent and isolated. That sometimes leaves the door open to control and abuse. Even without this dynamic, I think Monaco can be an intimidating place for women to integrate.”

He advises that if you are going to live in or around Monaco, it is helpful to know your relationship with money. “This is not the place to compete. There will always be someone out there with more. More money. More cars. More wives. I’ve worked with many successful business people who are trying to heal a childhood wound with the purchase of a larger yacht. It’s not going to happen. Heal the wound first and then think about the yacht.”

On Group Therapy
Gavin works with individuals and couples who are looking to make profound changes in their relationships and lives. “As a therapist, I wear many hats. Alongside my Masters in Integrative Psychotherapy, I am also trained in addiction, trauma and relationship and sex therapy. My services and workshops reflect this.”

He currently runs three weekly online groups – one exclusively for men, one for women and, as he is the only certified sex addiction therapist in the Riviera, the third is for male sex and love addicts.

He also holds intensive weekends throughout the year for people coming to terms with addiction. “One of my most popular workshops is my two-day couple’s wellbeing intensive. I love this workshop. It’s not so much about resolving problems – although it can be – but more about rediscovering love and building deeper intimacy and connection. We are all craving connection, pandemic or not.”

Connection is also part of what makes a good therapist. “I could have a hundred initials after my name but if we don’t have chemistry and click, I am likely to be the wrong therapist for you. Only work with me if you connect with me. That’s my mantra. The relationship is key.”

A good therapist will most likely have trained at a reputable educational establishment, ideally up to or beyond a Masters level. Therapy is an unregulated profession in the UK, so Gavin choose to be a member of several professional associations to ensure he is held accountable to the highest standards.

He underlines that a client also needs to feel that therapy offers a safe and confidential space, offline or online. “And comfortable chairs help!”

Attending a group is usually less expensive than attending one-to-one therapy which can be why some people chose only group sessions. “Let me say at the outset, I am passionate about groups. There is a lot of research which has tested the efficacy of groups. They can be transformational. Sometimes what we seek is an acknowledgment from others who have walked in our shoes and groups provide this collective empathy. Participants are able to see their pain in others and vice versa,” he emphasises.

“I don’t see group therapy as better but more as a therapy tool in the whole wellbeing toolkit. Many people find it helpful to participate in both group therapy and individual psychotherapy.”

Being a therapist on the French Riviera is unique. “I can go out for dinner and see three or four clients. My clients know that I will ignore them and respect their privacy. Sometimes we laugh about it in session.”

ON GAVIN
Like many of us, Gavin learned to mask his inward lack of confidence. “Growing up, we all experience attachment wounds – for example abuse, neglect, betrayal, loss or abandonment – and those wounds impact how loveable and worthy we believe ourselves to be. For a long time, I didn’t feel worthy and for a while, I disguised my wounds even from myself. I became what I thought others expected of me. It led to my success in the corporate world that I mentioned earlier but left a sense of emptiness inside,” he relates.

His upcoming show on Riviera Radio on March 3rd will address that inner critic and voice inside our head that often undermines our accomplishments leaving us feeling guilt and/or shame.

“I’ve learned to silence my inner critic. Of course, it crops up every now and then but like my clients, I, too, am always evolving,” says Gavin Sharpe. 

Remember to post your Pink Ribbon Monaco photos holding
a sign with a message of support this Sunday, February 14.
#seinvalentin #Pinkribbonmonaco